Aeration Wars: Spike vs. Plug | Lawn Fly

Team McFly Mar 12, 2023
13 People Read
man aerating lawn

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to me at no cost to you if you decide to purchase. This site is not intended to provide financial advice and is for entertainment only. 

Spike Aerator Vs. Plug Aerator

Aerating is a soil improvement method that breaks up compaction and allows air, water, and nutrients to reach your grassroots. Not only does this improve soil structure and make your lawn look its best, but it also reduces thatch, moss growth, and other issues.

Spike aerators utilize long, pointed spikes that dig holes into the ground to break up compacted soil and promote soil health. They are particularly effective in smaller areas with looser soils, such as around patios or footpaths.

spike aeration

What is a Spike Aerators

A spike aerator is a mechanical tool that creates holes in your lawn to promote airflow and encourage growth. These holes allow air, water, and nutrients to seep into the ground, giving your grassroots more nourishment.

Spike aerators also loosen up thatch, which blocks soil nutrients and sunlight. This is especially helpful for lawns with heavy thatch accumulation as it allows grass roots to penetrate deeper into the soil and receive essential nourishment.

Plug aerators are similar to spike aerators in that they create holes in the soil to break up compaction and allow air and water to move down into the root zone. This makes it easier for grass roots to grow, decreasing the risk of rainwater puddles in your lawn after rainfall.

plug aerator

What is a Plug Aerator

A plug aerator is a lawn aerator that removes soil cores and creates small holes in the ground. This helps relieve the pressure beneath the grassroots by allowing air, water, and nutrients to reach them more easily.

Over time, soil can become compacted due to regular lawn usage, construction activities, parking on the grass, and thatch buildup. When this occurs, grassroots struggle to get enough water, air, and nutrients they require for healthy growth.

Lawns established in clay soil require core aeration approximately twice a season. This is the most efficient way of de-compacting your yard and will keep your grass healthy and vibrant.

You have several options for plugging aerators: buy one, rent one or get a small manual version that you can carry on your lawn mower. Generally, renting an aerator is more cost-effective than purchasing one.

man aerating lawn

Lawn Size

Spike aerators are typically employed for lawns with moderate compaction, and they can be beneficial in reducing thatch and creating space for water and oxygen to seep into the soil. Furthermore, these tools help reduce weed growth in your lawn, improving its aesthetic appeal.

Aerators come in many forms, each designed for a particular task. Options include aerator shoes with narrow spikes protruding from the sole, hand-to-foot aerators, drum aerators, push aerators, and metal frames.

Plug aerators are more efficient at breaking up compacted soil and creating larger holes to let oxygen, water, and nutrients reach your grassroots. These tools can either be powered by you or pulled behind a lawn tractor.

Lawns with heavy clay soil often develop a thick layer of thatch--a mix of dead stems, leaves, and roots--that blocks drainage. A yearly pass with a lawn aerator creates space for air and water to penetrate deeply into the soil, promoting grass growth.

Soil Condition

Soil compaction occurs when soil becomes hard and restricts air, water, and nutrients that need to move freely through your lawn's root zone. This occurs gradually over time due to regular lawn usage, construction activities, and thatch buildup.

Spike aerators puncture the soil with long spikes, creating spaces for air, water, and fertilizer to circulate. They work best on less compacted soil or sod but may not be as effective when dealing with dense or heavy soil.

Plug aerators dig deeper into the soil, creating larger holes to relieve pressure. While this method works best on compacted soil, it may cause stress to grass during application.

Aeration helps restore soil and encourages healthier growth for your lawn. This process breaks up compaction, allowing water and nutrients to reach the roots of your grass. Furthermore, it reduces thatch buildup as well as soil erosion.

hand aerator

Types of Spike Aerators

Spike aerators use solid tines to penetrate and push your soil aside, improving airflow and encouraging plant growth. However, this method won't create deep holes necessary for compacting soil.

When selecting a spike aerator for your lawn, there are many types available to choose from. Your selection should consider factors like the size of your lawn, its soil condition, and whether or not you prefer regular or infrequent aeration.

Typically, plug aerators are the go-to choice for commercial lawns; however, hand-and-foot options also exist. These manual aerators can be perfect for smaller areas that don't get much foot traffic.

strap on shoe aerators

If you're searching for an easier way to aerate your lawn, rolling push spike aerators might be the way. These look like large paint rollers and work great on mildly compacted grass areas. Although these take some effort, the results can be impressive.

Types of Plug Aerators

Lawn care can be overwhelming with so many choices available. To find what works best for your individual needs and budget, knowing which option will fit best into each scenario is important.

A plug aerator is a mechanical lawn tool that removes small soil cores from your lawn, relieving compaction on the grassroots and allowing air, water, and nutrients to reach them more effectively.

Plug aerators are typically wheeled, similar to lawnmowers or seed spreaders. They feature short, hollow cylindrical protrusions on their axle that dig into the ground as you push them along.

Another type of aerator is a handheld tool with long spikes that you attach to your shoes. These tools work best for small lawns with loose soil.

Spike aerators are easier to use than plug aerators and work best on lawns with mild soil compaction. Furthermore, they can help eliminate minor thatch buildup.

What are the Pros and Cons of Spike Aeration?

Aeration is a lawn care practice that breaks up soil compaction and improves grass health. Aeration allows air, water, and nutrients to reach the root zone more readily, encouraging it to grow strong and healthy.

Core and spike aeration are two popular aeration methods with advantages and drawbacks. You should select which type of aeration works best for your lawn and soil conditions.

Spike aerators are an ideal solution for small lawns that don't have significant compaction issues or thatch buildup. After aeration, no unsightly plugs of soil will be left on the turf, making them suitable even for high-traffic areas.

Spike aerators can be useful when you need more surface area for fertilization or overseeding. However, they tend to be less effective than plug aerators at loosening compacted soil and pushing it down toward the sides of your turf.

In Conclusion

When it comes to aerating your lawn, plenty of methods are available. But which is best suited for your soil type, lawn size, and budget? That's the decision you must make.

Spike aerators use long spikes to create small holes in the ground, allowing water and nutrients to reach grass roots more effectively. This method works best for lawns with loose loam or sandy soils.

For larger lawns, a plug aerator is the best solution. Pushed deep into the ground by its solid tines, this aerator effectively removes plugs of dirt by pushing down into it; these larger models last longer than their smaller counterparts in terms of soil compaction reduction.

Selecting the appropriate aerator for your yard can make all the difference between a healthy lawn and one that fails. Spike aerators work best in small yards with loose or sandy soils, while plug aerators are indispensable when decompacting large areas of clay-based turf. See our recent article on Ultimate Guide to Aerating Your Lawn.

Related Featured Posts:

How to Use a Fertilizer and Seed Spreader

Your Guide to Spring Lawn Care: Lawn Fly

Disclosure:  Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to me at no cost to you if you decide to purchase. This site is not intended to provide financial advice and is for entertainment only.